By Chris Yong
Chris-yongmh@hotmail.com
Being at the top of the student hierarchy is not easy, especially when the student population didn’t get to elect them. I’m sure back when the 15th INTIMA executive committee was announced, we all ran similar thoughts in our head – Who are these people? What are their qualifications? How would they fare as the new student government? And then before you know it, everyone wants a piece of them – criticisms, doubts, rants – even before the team assumes their places in the office.
Being the typical Malaysian I am, I jumped onto the bandwagon as well; the new INTIMA team became a staple conversation topic in my “teh tarik sessions” for a few weeks. Then – also another typical Malaysian trait – I conveniently forgot about them, shifting my focus to things at hand that are more important.
But having worked closely with the INTIMA EXCO over the past few months, I can’t help but to feel that some earlier notions I had about them, good or bad, were premature and unjustified. In the following I shall talk about my opinion of the 15th INTIMA EXCO– a mid-term review – the good and the bad.
The good:
• Team Cohesion – Surprisingly, the INTIMA exco is a very cohesive team for a ragtag group of students. It’s not something that can be achieved easily, just take a look at any club committee out there, especially a big committee formed from people who do not share common previous experiences, it’s difficult to find a tight-knit group working as well and having great fun at the same time as the 15th INTIMA EXCO.
• Attitude – Generally, the 15th INTIMA EXCO are a very approachable bunch. Their friendliness can actually make you forget that you are talking to a student government member; it feels more like dealing with a friend you’ve known for years. They are very helpful to other students and clubs alike, providing assistance if need be. I’ve never felt a tinge of arrogance from them, only camaraderie.
• Media – I do feel like they have a better internet presence compared to the last term. The utilization of Facebook had allowed them to reach a larger audience, although I still think they are not using the Facebook mail function enough. The launch of their new independent forum (http://intimaforum.co.cc/) was also a good move, the overall layout of the forum was neatly designed and the forum is definitely superior to its counterpart at INTIonline; I would suggest INTIMA to stop using the public forum at INTIonline and move all student discussions to the new forum so that it’s easier for both parties.
The bad:
• Sense of Authority – The 15th INTIMA still does not command the respect from all the clubs. Having tried to display authority with a series of new stringent regulations, it served only to cause a sense of oppression among the affiliate clubs. A good government does not force people to obey rules, they try to have rational conversation, and make compromise for a mutually agreed decision. INTIMA EXCOs needs to have better justifications for the regulations they pass, because there are a couple of them that, frankly speaking, made little sense.
• Professionalism – This is a problem plaguing the office since their installment. Being at the top of the student hierarchy, we expect them to have a personal display on par with their position. If you are a member of the student government, you better start acting like one. Sometimes, one feels there is a lack of maturity in the way the INTIMA EXCOs display themselves – behavior, tone of speaking, handling matters. I do not mean that this is a perennial problem, but it happens enough to be noticeable by the INTI community.
• Identity Crisis – INTIMA has a dilemma, and they don’t know it. They are stuck between being the awesome friend and the elite student government. A government is supposed to be exclusive and unbiased; a government is not supposed to be swayed by someone into making a biased decision because that someone is a dear friend. I’m not suggesting that INTIMA is biased, but it’s hard not to imagine when their friends give them visit at the office so often. An office is called an office for a reason; it is a place where work is meant to be done. I’m not restricting the EXCO members from interacting with their friends – by all means, please do – but take it out of the office; it doesn’t do well for INTIMA’s credibility when friendship and official work gets tangled together.
The 15th INTIMA EXCO, while faring quite well so far, still has some room for improvements. That being said, INTIMA EXCO should really try a different approach in gaining more respect from the affiliate clubs, because whatever it is that they are doing right now, it’s not going too well. Also, if INTIMA is doing anything significant to contribute to the student population at all, the students have not seen it.
The ongoing issue with the fences at the hostel blocks will be a good litmus test for INTIMA’s credibility as the student representative, all eyes will be on them as we fight for our student rights. The outcome of this issue will greatly determine how we judge the 15th INTIMA EXCO, whether they are really a revolutionary student government or not.
Chris Yong is The Asterisk’s resident political writer. His thoughts and views are of his own volition and do not reflects the views of the general INTI population.